Andy Cohen Calls Bs He Thinks Jen Shah Gave Heather Gay That Black Eye Perez Hilton Andy Cohen Calls Bs He Thinks Jen Shah Gave Heather Gay That Black Eye Perez HiltonRhoslc Star Heather Gay Finally Admits Jen Shah Gave Her A Black EyeAndy Cohen Slams Jen Shah Over Her Story On Heather Gay S Black EyeJen Shah Slams Andy Cohen For Heather Gay S Claim She Gave Black EyeAndy Cohen Admits He Thinks Jen Shah Gave Heather A Black Eye On RhoslcAndy Cohen Slams ‘insane’ Jen Shah As A ‘liar’ After She Responds To Heather Gay’s Claim RhoslcAndy Cohen Thinks Jen Shah Gave ‘rhoslc’ Co Star Heather Gay Her Black Eye FlipboardI Don T Think She Hit Her Head Andy Cohen Suspects Jen Shah Gave Rhoslc Star Heather GayAndy Cohen Thinks Rhoslc Star Jen Shah Gave Heather Gay The Black Eye Celeb JabberJen Shah Slams ‘hurt’ Andy Cohen For Heather Gay’s Black Eye Reveal But Is She Lying YoutubeAndy Cohen Thinks Rhoslc Star Jen Shah Gave Heather Gay The Black EyeVideo See Jen Shah Reporting For Prison And Response To AndyAndy Cohen Claps Back At Jen Shah After Her Diss And Denial That She Gave Heather Gay A Black EyeJen Shah Responds To Andy Cohen S Theory That She Gave Heather Gay The Black EyeAndy Cohen Talks Jen Shah S Involvement With Heather Gay S EyeAndy Cohen Thinks Jen Shah Gave Heather Gay A Black EyeWatch Jen Shah And Heather Gay S Sit Down Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen Season 18Jen Shah Threatens To Sue Heather Gay Bravo Andy Cohen For Slander And Defamation FollowingAndy Cohen Talks Jen Shah S Involvement With Heather Gay S EyeRhoslc Jen Shah On Claims She Gave Heather Gay A Black Eye 247 News Around The WorldAndy Cohen Believes Jen Shah Gave Heather Gay A Black Eye On Rhoslc Taste Of RealityHeather Gay Reveals Jen Shah Gave Her The Black Eye Taste Of RealityRhoslc S Heather Gay Finally Reveals How She Got That Black Eye Media Take OutAndy Cohen S Theory On Who Really Gave Heather Gay A Black Eye Echoes What We Re All ThinkingJen Shah Slams ‘butthurt’ Andy Cohen For Heather Gay’s Black Eye Revelation ‘the Show Can’tWatch Is There Anything Jen Shah Could Do To Offend Heather Gay Watch What Happens Live WithJen Shah Denies Heather’s Claim That She Gave Her Black EyeJen Shah Speaks Out After Rhosc Co Star Heather Gay Claims She Gave Her Black EyeJen Shah Responds To Heather Gay S Claim That She Gave Her A Black Eye During “rhoslc ”finaleAndy Cohen Reveals Who Punched Heather Gay In The EyeJen Shah Denies Giving Heather Gay A Black Eye In Instagram Post While In PrisonRhoslc Fans Convinced Jen Shah Gave Heather Gay The Black EyeWatch Heather Gay On Jen Shah’s Questionable Business Activities Watch What Happens Live WithAndy Cohen Reacts To Rhoslc’s Jen Shah Guilty Plea Us WeeklyRhoslc Fans Shocked By Heather Gay S New Face On Wwhl